Reply to Thread

Message

<blockquote data-quote="sh00ter" data-source="post: 4078609" data-attributes="member: 24531">Well if he had been one of them he probably would be justified I&#039;m sure. Seriously though, tragedy...we&#039;d all need to have seen it to know the right/wrongs but it would take a lot to justify it. If I were a 62yo man with health issues, I would not want to be expected to fist fight some 25yo stranger...even if I got out of the car, I have a right to get in or out...if the other guy was a stranger and had a stark physical advantage and attempted to attack, I would think a DA would go easier in that case...I agree he should not get out of the car if that is what he did, but I have seen arguments that didn&#039;t get physical, so he could make a case that he had no bad intentions I suppose...still, none of us would think we would shoot anyone who was unarmed. But imagine if you don&#039;t know what the other person is capable of nor do you know if they have a weapon, etc. These deals are so bad!</blockquote>

[QUOTE="sh00ter, post: 4078609, member: 24531"] Well if he had been one of them he probably would be justified I'm sure. Seriously though, tragedy...we'd all need to have seen it to know the right/wrongs but it would take a lot to justify it. If I were a 62yo man with health issues, I would not want to be expected to fist fight some 25yo stranger...even if I got out of the car, I have a right to get in or out...if the other guy was a stranger and had a stark physical advantage and attempted to attack, I would think a DA would go easier in that case...I agree he should not get out of the car if that is what he did, but I have seen arguments that didn't get physical, so he could make a case that he had no bad intentions I suppose...still, none of us would think we would shoot anyone who was unarmed. But imagine if you don't know what the other person is capable of nor do you know if they have a weapon, etc. These deals are so bad! [/QUOTE]

Verification