Scope suggestions for a Savage 17HMR

[egriton]

I've just bought my first rifle and have been looking for the right scope.

A few questions?
a) "sweet 17" or "17 hot" scopes -- just a gimmick? If I use different weights/different velocities, doesn't that undermine the turret gradations?

b) I would really like a mil-dot scope so that I can accommodate for bullet drop, rather than adjusting elevation -- a newbie error?

c) Mueller is often pointed out as a great brand for the money. Does its optics clearly beat BSA, Barska, Simmons?

d) I suppose, any other advice? BTW, I'd like to stay <$150, preferably closer to $100.

Thanks.

 

[TwoForFlinching]

I've got a BSA sweet 17 3-9x40, and a 4-16x40 on two savages... Dead on with correct weight and sight height. The trick to them is the rings. I really hate BSA, but I love these scopes. Decently clear well beyond the affective range of the caliber. The 3-9 ran me $40 at academy. The 4-16 was $70. Definitely not a gimmick

 

[MoBoost]

My vote goes to another walmart offering: http://www.walmart.com/ip/CenterPoint-4-16x40mm-Scope/10248654

P.S. I've had very bad luck with newer BSA, Centerpoint has been on a bubba-Mosin for a few years with zero issues.

 

[Hoov]

After being burned by a bad batch of BSAs at SWO, I tend to shy away from them. I like the concept, but the execution was poor at the time.

 

[henschman]

Check this out. It is more than what you are looking for, but it is a kick ass scope for the money. Mil reticle with mil turrets, and a FFP reticle. http://www.midwayusa.com/product/45...il-adjustments-first-focal-mrad-reticle-matte