Lights were off in the apartment, I believe.
I cannot understand how a person is expected to recognize and obey a police order if you have no way to see that it is a law enforcement officer giving the order. ....Even if it were outdoors instead of in your own house.
I cannot understand how a person is expected to recognize and obey a police order if you have no way to see that it is a law enforcement officer giving the order. ....Even if it were outdoors instead of in your own house.
There have been thousands of cases where predators imitated LEO and their "lawful commands" to achieve their goals.
Update: the grand jury came back with murder, not manslaughter.
https://www.foxnews.com/us/grand-jury-dallas-officers-shooting-of-neighbor-was-murder
https://www.foxnews.com/us/grand-jury-dallas-officers-shooting-of-neighbor-was-murder
DALLAS – A white former Dallas police officer was indicted on a murder charge Friday, nearly three months after she fatally shot an unarmed black neighbor whose apartment she said she entered by mistake, believing it to be her own.
Amber Guyger told fellow officers that she opened fire when Botham Jean appeared in the darkness.
Jean's relatives joined the district attorney for the announcement of the charge. Jean, a 26-year-old native of the Caribbean island nation of St. Lucia, attended college in Arkansas and had been working in Dallas for accounting and consulting firm PwC.
"I truly believe that she inflicted tremendous evil on my son," Jean's mother, Allison said after the announcement. "He didn't deserve it. He was seated in his own apartment."
Guyger was arrested on a manslaughter charge three days after the Sept. 6 shooting, prompting criticism that the original charge was too lenient. But Johnson said at the time that the grand jury could upgrade the charge, which it did Friday.
"When you look at the facts of this case, we thought that it was murder all along," Dallas County District Attorney Faith Johnson said.
After finishing her shift, Guyger told investigators , she returned home in uniform and parked on the fourth floor of her apartment complex's garage, rather than the third floor, where her unit was located, according to an affidavit prepared by the Texas Rangers.
She said she got to what she thought was her apartment — Jean's was directly above hers — and found the door ajar. She opened it to find a figure standing in the darkness. She said she pulled her gun and fired twice after the person ignored her commands.
Guyger, 30, has since been fired from the department, and Jean's family has filed a lawsuit against Guyger and the city of Dallas. The federal suit argues that Guyger used excessive force in the shooting and contends the department did not give her adequate training.
The circumstances of the shooting sparked outrage and led many to question Guyger's account. Critics, including Jean's family, also wondered why it took three days for Guyger to be charged, why she was not taken into custody immediately after the shooting and whether race played a factor in her decision to use deadly force.
After the indictment was issued, Guyger turned herself in and posted bond a second time. She had been free on bond since her arrest.
With the murder charge, she faces up to life in prison if convicted. A manslaughter charge would have brought a sentence of up to 20 years.
Her attorney, Robert Rogers, said he was not surprised by the indictment, citing the political pressure surrounding the case and a wave of "vindictive emotion" targeting his client. He said Jean's mother testified before the grand jury, which he described as highly unusual.
During a news conference Friday, Jean family attorney Lee Merritt thanked the grand jury and said murder was the appropriate charge.
"This is groundbreaking, but it is also just a start," Merritt said. "We are focused on seeing this case through (to) a proper conviction and through an appropriate sentencing."
Dallas Police Chief Renee Hall said her department continues "to feel anguish" over the shooting. She described it as a "tragic event" and asked people to pray for Jean's family.
Jean's killing thrust Dallas into the national conversation about the intersection of race and law enforcement, a dialogue revived by the high-profile trials of officers charged with murder in police shootings.
In October, white Chicago officer Jason Van Dyke was found guilty of second-degree murder in the 2014 on-duty shooting of black teenager Laquan McDonald. Van Dyke shot McDonald 16 times.
And in August, white former Dallas-area officer Roy Oliver was convicted of murder for firing into a car filled with black teenagers leaving a house party in 2017. Fifteen-year-old Jordan Edwards was fatally shot.
Amber Guyger told fellow officers that she opened fire when Botham Jean appeared in the darkness.
Jean's relatives joined the district attorney for the announcement of the charge. Jean, a 26-year-old native of the Caribbean island nation of St. Lucia, attended college in Arkansas and had been working in Dallas for accounting and consulting firm PwC.
"I truly believe that she inflicted tremendous evil on my son," Jean's mother, Allison said after the announcement. "He didn't deserve it. He was seated in his own apartment."
Guyger was arrested on a manslaughter charge three days after the Sept. 6 shooting, prompting criticism that the original charge was too lenient. But Johnson said at the time that the grand jury could upgrade the charge, which it did Friday.
"When you look at the facts of this case, we thought that it was murder all along," Dallas County District Attorney Faith Johnson said.
After finishing her shift, Guyger told investigators , she returned home in uniform and parked on the fourth floor of her apartment complex's garage, rather than the third floor, where her unit was located, according to an affidavit prepared by the Texas Rangers.
She said she got to what she thought was her apartment — Jean's was directly above hers — and found the door ajar. She opened it to find a figure standing in the darkness. She said she pulled her gun and fired twice after the person ignored her commands.
Guyger, 30, has since been fired from the department, and Jean's family has filed a lawsuit against Guyger and the city of Dallas. The federal suit argues that Guyger used excessive force in the shooting and contends the department did not give her adequate training.
The circumstances of the shooting sparked outrage and led many to question Guyger's account. Critics, including Jean's family, also wondered why it took three days for Guyger to be charged, why she was not taken into custody immediately after the shooting and whether race played a factor in her decision to use deadly force.
After the indictment was issued, Guyger turned herself in and posted bond a second time. She had been free on bond since her arrest.
With the murder charge, she faces up to life in prison if convicted. A manslaughter charge would have brought a sentence of up to 20 years.
Her attorney, Robert Rogers, said he was not surprised by the indictment, citing the political pressure surrounding the case and a wave of "vindictive emotion" targeting his client. He said Jean's mother testified before the grand jury, which he described as highly unusual.
During a news conference Friday, Jean family attorney Lee Merritt thanked the grand jury and said murder was the appropriate charge.
"This is groundbreaking, but it is also just a start," Merritt said. "We are focused on seeing this case through (to) a proper conviction and through an appropriate sentencing."
Dallas Police Chief Renee Hall said her department continues "to feel anguish" over the shooting. She described it as a "tragic event" and asked people to pray for Jean's family.
Jean's killing thrust Dallas into the national conversation about the intersection of race and law enforcement, a dialogue revived by the high-profile trials of officers charged with murder in police shootings.
In October, white Chicago officer Jason Van Dyke was found guilty of second-degree murder in the 2014 on-duty shooting of black teenager Laquan McDonald. Van Dyke shot McDonald 16 times.
And in August, white former Dallas-area officer Roy Oliver was convicted of murder for firing into a car filled with black teenagers leaving a house party in 2017. Fifteen-year-old Jordan Edwards was fatally shot.
Possibly, but that'll be up to the DA. Grand juries don't make tactical decisions like "charge high and negotiate down;" they just weigh the evidence presented and decide whether it is sufficient to bring charges.
If the GJ decided on murder, that means they think there's enough to make murder stick, and the prosecutor decided to actually push the case (he could easily have put on a weak case if he wanted to). Granted, a good prosecutor could get a GJ to indict a ham sandwich, but I suspect there's a real case here.
I read several articles on this incident and do not believe the female officer committed murder. I do believe that she was reckless, overconfident, overbearing and should never have worn a badge. In my little mind, her actions amount to voluntary manslaughter. Although we will never know the truth in the matter, I speculate that when accosted by a uniformed officer, the victim (in all probability) contributed to the confusion, intensity and violence that ensued.....
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I don't know.....I don't see murder either. I see negligent homicide, or something like that. DA's are a political office, I can see the DA bending to political bias to keep the job.
Dad and I were speculating about the basis for a murder charge. Our theory is based in the "felony murder" rule, wherein any death occurring during the commission of a felony is automatically murder; the underlying felony in this case could be pointing the gun, discharging the gun, or any of several others. It could also be that other evidence was presented to the GJ that makes it look like less of an honest mistake than her PR folks have been suggesting.
Similar threads
