My guess is 4.5If these bucks were harvested off my farm in central Oklahoma, I would say your guess is close to about right. Out west, the body size and antler development is really dependent on the rain fall and crops around my farm from year to year. Here’s one off the central farm last year that body size was small but I guessed him at 5.5-7.5. Take a some guesses and I’ll let you know what the taxidermist said he was.View attachment 184271
I’m going to say that your taxidermist said 3 1/2 and I bet he’s wrong
Not being a smart butt but just because he can mount deer doesn’t mean he can age them