This is much the situation on my street, only with five houses, two of which would not care about fiber optic. Windstream has FO in the subdivision across the street, and they’re claiming they’ll get an extension to my street sometime this year... Maybe.
Update: we called Windstream (Kinetic) last week for the latest info, and they admitted they have no plans to bring their fiber optic 200 yards across the main road to just a couple houses on my street. They did lower my monthly fee $5 (woo woo) but per mbps download, I’m still paying more than 10X what the folks with FO across the street are paying. So I’m giving Starlink another look, but man, the startup fee of $600+, and paying several hundred dollars per year more for service, are giving me pause even with 3X to 10X the download speed I currently have.