Bookers Bourbon Fans

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

kingfish

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Mar 23, 2022
Messages
860
Reaction score
1,913
Location
Inola
The "Pappy" phenomenon came to mind as well, but Bookers isn't an ultra aged type of bourbon. It's aged 7-8 years while the "Pappy" bourbons in the Van Winkle line are aged 15, 20, or 23 years. I'm not saying that the extra aging justifies such a high price tag, but it's at least SOME reason to buy a stupidly expensive bourbon. Bookers is simply reducing the supply and raising the price.
So because of this Pappy phenomenon have you tried to buy a bottle of Weller Special Reserve lately? They are both under the banner of Buffalo Trace Distillery. Somewhere along the line the consuming public decided it is a poor man's version of Pappy because it has the same mash bill. It has now become unobtainium. If you do an internet search for it on the secondary market, you will see prices for $100 or more for a bottle that used to sell for about $25.

I have been a Scotch drinker for many years, but decided to try to get back into Bourbon drinking having not consumed any for 40 years or so. I remembered when I did drink it, I liked the Weller so I went a bought a bottle at some store. No big deal. Guess I just got lucky. When I went back for another, I was told they were out, and that everyone was out. I called Parkhill's, the biggest store in Tulsa. They said there was none to be had in the state. So this kicked my hoarder response into overdrive. I began a hard target search of every... The stores I called that did have some kept it hidden in the back room and would only sell one bottle at a time. I found another store that did have the 1.75l bottles on the shelf so I bought 2 of them. So far no one has been jacking up the price. When I find it, it's pretty much normal retail. Anyway I have managed to store up about 7 liters of the stuff so maybe by the time I consume all that, people will have come to their senses and realize it is nothing special and have moved on to the next craze. I'm actually reluctant to try any other Bourbons being afraid I will like it better then wonder what I am going to do with all this swill I have in the cabinet.
 

jakeman

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
4,596
Reaction score
6,689
Location
Blanchard, America
So because of this Pappy phenomenon have you tried to buy a bottle of Weller Special Reserve lately? They are both under the banner of Buffalo Trace Distillery. Somewhere along the line the consuming public decided it is a poor man's version of Pappy because it has the same mash bill. It has now become unobtainium. If you do an internet search for it on the secondary market, you will see prices for $100 or more for a bottle that used to sell for about $25.

I have been a Scotch drinker for many years, but decided to try to get back into Bourbon drinking having not consumed any for 40 years or so. I remembered when I did drink it, I liked the Weller so I went a bought a bottle at some store. No big deal. Guess I just got lucky. When I went back for another, I was told they were out, and that everyone was out. I called Parkhill's, the biggest store in Tulsa. They said there was none to be had in the state. So this kicked my hoarder response into overdrive. I began a hard target search of every... The stores I called that did have some kept it hidden in the back room and would only sell one bottle at a time. I found another store that did have the 1.75l bottles on the shelf so I bought 2 of them. So far no one has been jacking up the price. When I find it, it's pretty much normal retail. Anyway I have managed to store up about 7 liters of the stuff so maybe by the time I consume all that, people will have come to their senses and realize it is nothing special and have moved on to the next craze. I'm actually reluctant to try any other Bourbons being afraid I will like it better then wonder what I am going to do with all this swill I have in the cabinet.

Buffalo Trace is pretty good stuff, but also a little hard to source.

The new bourbon drinkers are making it difficult on us old drunks. Young whippersnappers!!
 

beardking

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Aug 8, 2013
Messages
5,243
Reaction score
12,627
Location
Norman
George and Evan good friends to have

The last post from this was from 2017. You definitely earned this. 😂 😂

1648653050422.png
 

OKRuss

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 12, 2017
Messages
2,410
Reaction score
5,357
Location
Tuttle, OK
Buffalo Trace is pretty good stuff, but also a little hard to source.

The new bourbon drinkers are making it difficult on us old drunks. Young whippersnappers!!
Jakeman, picked up a 1L of Buffalo Trace at Byron's a week or so back. Along with some Russell's Reserve and going to try the Evan Williams white label bottled in bond. Finished up the last of Elijah Craig small batch and I was impressed especially for the price.
 

jakeman

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
4,596
Reaction score
6,689
Location
Blanchard, America
Jakeman, picked up a 1L of Buffalo Trace at Byron's a week or so back. Along with some Russell's Reserve and going to try the Evan Williams white label bottled in bond. Finished up the last of Elijah Craig small batch and I was impressed especially for the price.

I’ll give Byron’s a try next time I’m thru there.

Appreciate the heads up! You’re a gentleman for revealing your source!!

My regular place keeps the BT & B’s in the back, and unless you know to ask for it and the owner is there to approve, it’s a no go. Fortune favors the bold. Gotta just be bold and ask sometimes. All they can do is say no. They can’t kill ya and eat ya.
 

OKRuss

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 12, 2017
Messages
2,410
Reaction score
5,357
Location
Tuttle, OK
I’ll give Byron’s a try next time I’m thru there.

Appreciate the heads up! You’re a gentleman for revealing your source!!

My regular place keeps the BT & B’s in the back, and unless you know to ask for it and the owner is there to approve, it’s a no go. Fortune favors the bold. Gotta just be bold and ask sometimes. All they can do is say no. They can’t kill ya and eat ya.
Us "tri city" folks have to stick together!! Raised in Newcastle, currently in Tuttle.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom