Most Over Rated?

[Hworth18]

I'd have to say pretty much any HK...but that's just my opinion.

I also think the PPK series of guns, at least the modern versions, could be.

Agreed....

 

[GorillaG]

Glock with it's wonderful brick in my hand feel.

Hated Glocks for a long time, I was a 1911 and Hi Power guy dyed in the wool, but I got a job and had to carry for 12 hour shifts, that 1911 brick got pretty heavy by the end of the day so I switched to my little S&W 36 Chiefs special, but my capacity and accuracy suffered. When Glocks became popular I said I'd never use some plastic toy gun but when I saw how much lighter they were, accurate, high capacity and most importantly dependable I got hooked. the 1911 and hi powers will always have my heart but for CC its strictly Glock.

 

[ParrotPirate]

This is a question I will definitely bite on. A lot of the more collectible handguns out there were revolutionary in their day but obsolete now. I can think of a lot of wierd guns that suck to shoot, but it makes sense they are collectible like automags, or old derringers so I don’t count those as overrated. So with that in mind, and with the benefit of hindsight I do not understand why the Detonics guns are so sought after. They feel and look cheap and compared to the other gimmicked 1911s from their day they are 4x the price. In their day you couldn’t get a lot of 3inch 1911s but now they are a dime a dozen so it makes no sense to me that the Detonics Combat Master would be worth $2000 in todays market even as a collector’s piece.

 

[GorillaG]

This is a question I will definitely bite on. A lot of the more collectible handguns out there were revolutionary in their day but obsolete now. I can think of a lot of wierd guns that suck to shoot, but it makes sense they are collectible like automags, or old derringers so I don’t count those as overrated. So with that in mind, and with the benefit of hindsight I do not understand why the Detonics guns are so sought after. They feel and look cheap and compared to the other gimmicked 1911s from their day they are 4x the price. In their day you couldn’t get a lot of 3inch 1911s but now they are a dime a dozen so it makes no sense to me that the Detonics Combat Master would be worth $2000 in todays market even as a collector’s piece.

I think they're valued mostly because they were the smallest 1911 ever made when they first came out, I recall even back then they were very expensive. Now I think it's just a question of scarcity that demands the high prices. I'd sure as hell never pay what they bring.

 

[ParrotPirate]

I think they're valued mostly because they were the smallest 1911 ever made when they first came out, I recall even back then they were very expensive. Now I think it's just a question of scarcity that demands the high prices. I'd sure as hell never pay what they bring.

Indeed. It’s what they call a cult following I guess. I have one of those ODI Vikings and I guarantee they made fewer of those than the Detonics but it’s practically worthless.

 

[jimbo74]

Sig p320

EVERYONE was going crazy for them in CA. They get the wierd ones too, that have to pass the roster

 

[OKCShooter]

Most overrated for the money spent?

Any Custom 1911

 

[Camo]

Glock with it's wonderful brick in my hand feel.

This

 

[mtngunr]

Depends on how you define overrated...by consumer or manufacturer?
In the manufacturer catagory, Glock takes the cake to such a degree everyone copied them...
historically they cost $125 to produce and sold for multiples over that production cost, which no handgun maker had ever done (or dared do) before, ushering the age of legal rape.

 

[CHenry]

Ed Brown 1911, cost is stupid to me. Dan Wesson 1911 is a close second.
My Ruger SR1911 is just fine for the $600 I paid for it here on OSA. It already had a flawless cerekote job too. Shoots accurate and every time. My EDC most days, either that or my Springfield XDM.