Does it have a rifle buffer? Looking at that A2 stock, I would bet it does.
Carbine gas system with a rifle length buffer shouldn't cause a problem, but....
If you have a buddy with a carbine buffer/lower/extension set up, you could swap lowers and see if she still short strokes.
That'd be pretty unreal if that's what it was. I ran a mid-gas 16" (Del-Ton barrel) with A2 buffer system reliably.