Which shotgun should I keep?

[h8ns8n]

I have several 12 gauge shottys and I think I want to thin the herd. I have a home defense one that I will keep for that purpose alone but would like to have an all-purpose type hunting one as well.
I have a Mossberg 500ag and a Remington 870 both of which I will probably let go but I would like advice between the remaining two on which one to keep.
I have a nice Remington 1100 with a mod choke and a 28" barrel and a like new Mossberg 935 that is only a 24" rifled barrel, are there any pros/cons to these two and which one would be the best choice for an all purpose field gun? Or should I get rid of all of them and get something with different chokes? Thanks for the input

 

[jalapeno]

wow ok all good shottys in their own right. the 500 is one of those that has a million after market accessories as well as the 870 both good solid pump guns. now as far as the semi autos that is kind of a toss up but it really depends on what you expect from the one you will keep. one point is I believe the mossberg barrels are cheaper so you could change out the barrel on the 935. but the remington is a good solid workhorse. I say keep the one that feels better to you and the one that you shoot the best. just my .02

 

[aestus]

I say keep the remington 870 and sell the rest. Use that money to buy something else or wait till a good deal for a Benelli m2 to pop up.

 

[langston302]

Keep The 870 _Sell the Rest

 

[h8ns8n]

just help me understand (because my shotgun knowledge is very limited) why choose the 870 pump over the 1100 semi-auto for hunting purposes?

 

[O4L]

I have owned most, and have hunted with all of the shotguns you have.

I prefer the Remington 1100.

I started out with the 1100, went to pumps for many years, and went back to the 1100.

 

[Ignored Member]

Sell em all and get a Benelli M2 for hunting and a Benelli Nova for home defense.

 

[Glocktogo]

Sell em all and get a Benelli M2 with two barrels.

 

[Sanjuro82]

Keep the 870 and get rid of the rest.

 

[dennishoddy]

Keep the 1100 for hunting and home defense.