Zimmerman's lawyers drop him

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

elwoodtrix

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
May 9, 2009
Messages
7,743
Reaction score
10,374
Location
OKC
How does Martin know Zimmerman has a gun? The only way he would know is if Zimmerman had drawn down on him. I would believe if Martin had seen a gun, he would have fled rather than go fist fighting with a man that had a gun drawn.

I guess judging by your post it is acceptable to beat the **** out of anyone that is following you. I'm sure Martin would have been on the defensive about some dude following him but just because someone is tailing you does that give you the right to attack?

pure speculation..

kid should have called 911 right?? "some dude following me in his vehicle... hold on, wait, he got out and is running after me because I tried to get away from him"
 
Joined
Jan 12, 2007
Messages
30,011
Reaction score
17,608
Location
Collinsville
following you with a gun... come on man.. here have some skittles, taste the rainbow..

corner a dog, see what happens

Are you saying Martin is a "dog"? Do you have evidence that Zimmerman had him "cornered"? Do you have evidence that Martin knew Zimmerman had a gun?

pure speculation..

kid should have called 911 right?? "some dude following me in his vehicle... hold on, wait, he got out and is running after me because I tried to get away from him"

Why couldn't Martin have called 911? He had a phone in his hand, didn't he? Do you have evidence that Zimmerman was "running" after Martin?

Pure speculation is EXACTLY what you're engaging in. :(
 

farmerbyron

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Nov 3, 2008
Messages
5,289
Reaction score
152
Location
Tuttle
pure speculation..

kid should have called 911 right?? "some dude following me in his vehicle... hold on, wait, he got out and is running after me because I tried to get away from him"


This case is fraught with speculation. You speculated that Martin knew Zimmerman had a gun and felt cornered. Many unknowns in this case but it has been reported since day one as a kid gets profiled and gunned down by a larger, grown man. Reality and facts have had very little bearing to this point.
 

Stephen Cue

Sharpshooter
Joined
Jan 17, 2008
Messages
3,837
Reaction score
6
Location
West Tulsa
So by your interpretation, you give up the right to self defense if you first flee? Or just that SYG does not apply if you first flee? In which case you still have a right to self defense under the laws previous to SYG. I can see no scenario where you would lose the protection of the law if you practice lawful self defense. I think you are taking things a little bit too literally without regard to the intent and practice of the law.

Never said he GAVE UP the right to self-defense due to fleeing. I stated SYG does not apply IF one flees first. IT DOESNT NEED TO BE APPLIED.

AGAIN... SYG states you do not have to flee. When someone flees first, then is forced to defend themselves, they are in a much better legal position than what is covered under SYG because they tried to flee first.

One more time....If someone assaults you, you flee, they follow and attack, you defend yourself, SYG does not apply because it does not need to and it does not fit the criteria of the law. SYG only applies when one in fact....STANDS THEIR GROUND at the onset of the attack.


:)

Where Zimmermans trouble may lie is that he could be perceived as the agitator and brought the attack on himself. However, the other side of the coin is that if he was simply reporting suspicious activity and being in a place he has a legal right to be , was then attacked, stood his ground and met force with force then he would have the protection of the law.

Fixed it for ya :thumbup3:

^^^This.^^^^

see above post. :)

I tend to view "stand your ground" as a silly bit of legislative overkill if it is already lawful for one to exercise self defense. It's probably not a popular opinion to have on a shooters forum, but it seems like "stand your ground" laws are really more "stick it to the man" laws.

No, not a popular opinion here, but a respected one. :respect:

SYG may be "overkill" but when it comes to being criminally/civilly charged with the chances of prison or financial ruin, I am glad there is the extra specificity that protects me. I dont trust my life to a wishful optimistic interpretation.
 

Lurker66

Sharpshooter
Joined
Aug 14, 2012
Messages
9,332
Reaction score
8
Location
Pink
I guess its fun to speculate. I speculate there will be a trial and the judge will beat the gavel to close the case. Until then play the guessing game, blame the media, argue pointless angles and build up your post count.
 

tRidiot

Perpetually dissatisfied
Special Hen
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
19,521
Reaction score
12,715
Location
Bartlesville
I guess its fun to speculate. I speculate there will be a trial and the judge will beat the gavel to close the case. Until then play the guessing game, blame the media, argue pointless angles and build up your post count.

We're here to talk, shoot the breeze and discuss current events, offer our opinions, etc.

At least I am.

What's a post count?
 

BadgeBunny

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Feb 5, 2007
Messages
38,213
Reaction score
16
Location
Port Charles
We're here to talk, shoot the breeze and discuss current events, offer our opinions, etc.

At least I am.

What's a post count?

Everything to someone who doesn't have one ... LOL

I've never figured out why when in a "conversation" here someone will get their panties wadded up and throw out the post count thing. This guys here (the vast majority of them long gone -- or just lurkers -- now :cry11:) would chitty-chat all night long. We had some downright EPIC threads here ... and they were all hysterical. I spent many nights laughing so hard I was crying ... :kiss:

Oh ... and I have no idea how this one's gonna go ... All I know for sure is that convicted or not Zimmerman's life has been FUBAR'd beyond belief -- first, when he shot the kid (whether it was self-defense or not) and second, when Travon's Mommy and Daddy decided their less-than-perfect angel's name needed to be trademarked ...
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom