Good experience flying on American out of OKC with checked pistol

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Apr 18, 2009
Messages
435
Reaction score
132
Location
Yale
Last week my wife and I flew out of OKC for our anniversary in New York City. I had read all the laws and checked both American Airlines and the TSA websites before the trip. I bought a key locked metal safe from Academy for $19.99 that had a security cable allowing me to loop it around the inside of my suitcase so the case couldn't be removed. I packed my unloaded Kahr PM9, two empty magazines and a factory box of twenty rounds inside the metal safe and locked it with the key. Then I packed the whole thing inside of my luggage that was to be checked.

When we got to the counter at 0400, the lady at the counter was super pleasant. She asked me to verbally confirm that it was an unloaded handgun then had me sign a declaration form which was placed inside of the luggage. She never asked to see the safe or gun whatsoever. The bag was tagged and sent along with my wife's checked luggage. The bag made it through our connections in Chicago and I picked it up from the baggage carousel in New York City without a problem.

When we flew out from New York City on Saturday afternoon at 1400 it was way different. I had re-packed my bag just the same and declared the unloaded handgun in my luggage at the counter. The lady was very professional and stepped away to make a "phone call." While she was on the phone, she stepped back to me and asked if I was an LEO, I told her yes and that put her at ease. It made me nervous when she shut down her counter to wait but did not say what we were waiting on. Soon two uniformed NYPD Officers showed up and were joined by a third.

The contact officer was nice and confirmed that I was checked an unloaded handgun. He then asked for my identification including driver's license and LE cards. He took down my information including my cell phone then asked to see my gun. We were still at the counter but I opened my bag and fished out the safe. He asked me to open it and watched as I produced the key which is supposed to remain only in my possession. He wanted to record the make, model and serial number but did not have me show it was unloaded nor did he look at the ammunition. He had me lock it up again and the ticket agent had me sign the same type of declaration form as I had done in OKC. Then we all waited until a porter came to assist and he carried the bag while we rode down to the lower levels of La Guardia. It was down to just the Officer, my wife and I by that time.

Downstairs we waited while the porter and Officer went with my bag to another room to meet with TSA I believe. Soon afterwards the officer returned and walked back with us upstairs. He was really nice and professional the entire time. We had been given our tickets before going downstairs and we were ready to go get a bite to eat before catching our flight.

It was interested that I did not have any "inspected by TSA" notices inside of my bag after either flight.

Andrew
 

Foghorn

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Sep 5, 2009
Messages
854
Reaction score
177
Location
OKC
Never been through new york (new jersey was bad enough), but I've never had anyone record my serial number? Kind of confused by that one.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G891A using Tapatalk
 

tRidiot

Perpetually dissatisfied
Special Hen
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
19,521
Reaction score
12,715
Location
Bartlesville
Yes... I'm not sure I would have liked how much hassle they made it in NYC. Certainly having the police take official notice and record all my information including DL, cell phone number and the make, model and serial number of my handgun is not what I would consider hassle-free. What, exactly, is the city of NY and state of NY going to do with that information they just gathered on you, a tourist who carries weapons? Where is it going to be stored? Who is going to have access to it? Is it going to affect future travel in and through NY state or other points? I don't like it. I don't like it at all. You did nothing wrong. And you're a law enforcement officer??? Jesus, I can't imagine how deep the body-cavity search would have been on just some plain ol' law-abiding jackass like me.

FFS, man, terrorists don't declare their f***ing weapons at the counter, you dipshits.
 

tRidiot

Perpetually dissatisfied
Special Hen
Joined
Oct 23, 2009
Messages
19,521
Reaction score
12,715
Location
Bartlesville
No doubt... no way I would have. But then, being a LEO, I guess you have that right? We common schlubs don't, I don't think. NYC doesn't even allow its own citizens to OWN a gun without a permit and being registered, from the way I understand it. Even keeping one in your own home, not carrying daily on the streets. That's absolute freaking stupidity, to me. I just can't fathom that. So I can't see where a tourist could carry a firearm or bring it with them on vacation even just to keep in the hotel room, unless they were an LEO like you, right?

I am making assumptions here, from what little I do actually know, which is why I am asking.
 

mugsy

Sharpshooter
Supporting Member
Special Hen Supporter
Joined
May 20, 2011
Messages
4,538
Reaction score
1,112
Location
South West, OK
I travel often with a handgun checked in my luggage. I can tell you from my research that, unless you are LEO, do NOT try to carry a personal weapon into a NYC airport. You run a very high risk of being detained, at the least, and possibly arrested. NY State does not recognize any other State's license and they make it well known that they will make an example of anyone who tries to flout their very restrictive gun laws.
 

BryanDP

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 6, 2007
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
323
Location
Tulsa
LGA > TUL doesn't sound very hassle-free to me! I wonder what would have happened if you had not been a LEO?

As a non-LEO I've flown several times with a gun without incident. The strangest ever was New Orleans where the ticket counter agent actually had me remove the gun and "pull that thing back" to show her that it was unloaded. I've also had a few ticket agents that didn't know the rules and I've politely educated them. One time my bag got lost and I'm pretty sure the fact that it contained a firearm got it extra attention in its locating. I recommend everyone travel with a firearm even if it's just a starter pistol!

Bryan
 
Joined
Dec 9, 2008
Messages
87,561
Reaction score
69,696
Location
Ponca City Ok
I travel often with a handgun checked in my luggage. I can tell you from my research that, unless you are LEO, do NOT try to carry a personal weapon into a NYC airport. You run a very high risk of being detained, at the least, and possibly arrested. NY State does not recognize any other State's license and they make it well known that they will make an example of anyone who tries to flout their very restrictive gun laws.

Your dammed lucky you are an LEO. It would have been really bad if not. The NRA had to come to the defense of a guy that had a flight diverted to NYC because of weather. He declared his gun, and was arrested and a big court fight developed.
I've flown with a pistol many times, but never to NY.
The only issue I've ever had was at the Denver airport on a flight where we had to change flights/carrier. In OKC, no problem. In Denver, the counter lady said just a minute when I declared.
TSA agent escorted the wife and I to another room with my bag. Guy took it, scanned it with a wand, and put it on a conveyor. We were free to go. I suspect a scan for explosives? Don't know. Not scary at all, just a little additional hassle.
 

BryanDP

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 6, 2007
Messages
2,803
Reaction score
323
Location
Tulsa
In Denver, the counter lady said just a minute when I declared. TSA agent escorted the wife and I to another room with my bag. Guy took it, scanned it with a wand, and put it on a conveyor. We were free to go. I suspect a scan for explosives? Don't know. Not scary at all, just a little additional hassle.

I forgot about Denver and the walk down to the TSA room. The weird thing is they go through all that hassle and then send your bag back with a porter in the non-secure area back to the conveyor belt at the ticket counter. I think I was the first person ever who insisted on walking my bag back with him and watching it go into the TSA secure area. What if that guy had put something in there after I left it with him? Or what if he just walked off with it after knowing it had a valuable firearm in it? Their methods seemed flawed to me, but I guess they know best.

The weird thing is that every airport thinks they're doing it the "right" way, yet there are subtle differences everywhere you go. Of course they don't know this because they only work there. I've told several that everyone does it different but I don't think they believe me.
 
Joined
Dec 9, 2008
Messages
87,561
Reaction score
69,696
Location
Ponca City Ok
I forgot about Denver and the walk down to the TSA room. The weird thing is they go through all that hassle and then send your bag back with a porter in the non-secure area back to the conveyor belt at the ticket counter. I think I was the first person ever who insisted on walking my bag back with him and watching it go into the TSA secure area. What if that guy had put something in there after I left it with him? Or what if he just walked off with it after knowing it had a valuable firearm in it? Their methods seemed flawed to me, but I guess they know best.

The weird thing is that every airport thinks they're doing it the "right" way, yet there are subtle differences everywhere you go. Of course they don't know this because they only work there. I've told several that everyone does it different but I don't think they believe me.

Your right, it was different for me. Once the TSA guy wanded it, he put it on a conveyor that took it into the roof, never to be seen again until getting back to OKC.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom