Yessir that is sound logic but the problem is that the 22 year old horse raised my 14 year old daughter and he’s now raising my 8 year old daughter. So for me he probably has more sentimental value since he’s taken care of those girls and he’s not worth as much money as this 17 year old horse. I believe the values you put on both horses to be right in line with what I think.If hamster is kid friendly why not sell the 22 year old to a guaranteed good kid home?
Prices have gone through the roof. You used to be able to pick up a good grade gelding that had been slaved for a couple years in the feedlots up north for 2500 from the Mexicans in the winter when jackpots were the furthest thing from anyone’s mind and nobody was buying. Good using horses that could drag a fat up out of the lot and had some outside sense to them. They want 7500 now.
Your horse oughta be worth north of 10 with as much cow as he showed in those videos though, even at his age.
Edited to add that your 22 year old kid horse is probably worth 5 or more the right buyer. It’s crazy, but there’s no good horses out there for less.