I just got the Bushnell Elite 4200 from Cabelas for $179 with free shipping. The glass on that thing is awesome. Most of the reviews I read placed it in the same level as the Leupold VX-III.
Do you have the box handy? What is the model number. I just ordered the Bushnell Elite from Cheaper than Dirt and it didn't say 4200. The one I got is:
Manufacturer: Bushnell E3940SF
UPC: 029757010315