Backup Gun Dilemma

[Commander Keen]

I have recently decided that I both need and want a backup gun, something of the "fits in my pocket" variety.

Thus far I have narrowed down my options to two guns (though if I find another good candidate I would certainly consider that as well): a S&W 642 and a Diamondback Db9.

A primary argument for the s&w is its legendary reliability. Also, any needed replacement parts should be easy to come by. However, I have very little experience with wheelguns and this may require a good amount of training to get used to.

So far as the Db9 goes, it is in a caliber I already own, is pretty similar to my edc G30, and has better sights than the s&w.

So, there you have it. My big dilemma. Any input or ideas that might help narrow this down (or perhaps broaden my choices) would be appreciated!

 

[F16mickey]

I would go with the 38 special over the 380
I also feel that a revolver is generally better at the bug role.

 

[ExSniper]

I like the Db9 and the idea of staying with an auto to backup an auto

 

[Commander Keen]

I would go with the 38 special over the 380
I also feel that a revolver is generally better at the bug role.

The db9 is a 9mm. What are your thoughts on why a wheelgun is better than an auto in the bug role?

 

[WFT]

The wheelgun will go BANG EVERY time. Downside, it's a little bulky to carried in the pants pocket.

 

[F16mickey]

Sorry I automaticaly think 380 when I think DB.
My thoughts on back-ups are
If your primary is broke/jammed bad enough where you are going to backup things will more than likely be at contact distance.
the revo can be shoved into something without the worry of it getting knocked out of battery.
even if the revo is grabbed the cylinder will still turn. the auto will more than likely jam if/when it fires.

 

[Glock 'em down]

PM sent...

 

[ripnbst]

Can I ask the grounds for your determination of "needing" a BUG?

You could simply say I just want one and thats reason enough but since you said you "both need and want" I am curious what your determined NEED is?

 

[Commander Keen]

Can I ask the grounds for your determination of "needing" a BUG?

You could simply say I just want one and thats reason enough but since you said you "both need and want" I am curious what your determined NEED is?

My "need" is very much subjective, and is much more of a want.

Regardless, it's still something nice to have and could be fun at the range...

 

[Jefpainthorse]

Pocketed revolvers get FULL of lint... and still operate. Consider that that lint accumulates in pocket holster too. Can you imagine what crud could get in a gun loose in a pocket?

I'd expect any semi auto in the same pocket would need a lot more attention to keep it running.

I can get a SW 60 in a pair of Wranglers... it's a cinch in cargo pants or dress trousers with bigger pockets.