401k contribution - Yay or Nay

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

Raido Free America

Radio Free America
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 24, 2020
Messages
2,461
Reaction score
2,819
Location
Tulsa, OK.
A lot to unpack. Depends on your age, when you want to retire, do you have a cash reserve, what you believe will happen with the economy. The Dave Ramsey thing is a populist argument, but valid in some situations. So, I will assume you are five years or more away from retirement, have a minimum amount of savings, not a ton of debt aside from your mortgage. If you have debt if it is at a low rate (auto loan under 5%) why pay it off quicker? Inflation is high right now, better off using someone else's money. If you feel good about your long term job prospects and have a good cash reserve, why not take advantage of free company money? Investing monthly in a stock fund means your dollar cost averaging, and if the market is fluctuating you are acquiring more shares with each purchase. The market typically rights itself over a 5 to 10 year period.

Never forget too, the 401K gives you tax savings, but if you are in the 22% tax bracket you are only saving $220 for every $1000 you invest.

If you feel everything will go to heck then invest in Guns, MRE's, Survival food and Ammo.
That is one point of view, but I know people in their 70s/80's that have a stock of guns, ammo, MRE's and survival food, that are not able to work, working at Wal Mart, trying to cope with this OUT OF CONTROL INFLATION! It takes money to live after e retirement!
 

Raido Free America

Radio Free America
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 24, 2020
Messages
2,461
Reaction score
2,819
Location
Tulsa, OK.
Ignore Dave Ramsey here, ALWAYS contributed at least the company match. That’s free money, if you would have put in 6 they would have put in 6 (12% of your income saved pre tax) you’d still be ahead even if the stock market dropped 49%.
Find a stock market chart from a reliable sorce, and look at WHAT THE STOCK MARKET HAS ACTUALLY DONE THE LAST 100 YEARS, INCLUDING THE GREAT DEPRESSION! This is fact, not rumor, and the chart looks like Mt EVEREST, and continually goes up, with dips! Sure the entire world economy could crash, and burn, but if that happens, the only thing that will matter is food, and ammo! We must plan for what is likely to happen!
 
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
4,781
Reaction score
9,931
Location
Oklahoma City
That is one point of view, but I know people in their 70s/80's that have a stock of guns, ammo, MRE's and survival food, that are not able to work, working at Wal Mart, trying to cope with this OUT OF CONTROL INFLATION! It takes money to live after e retirement!
Agree with much of that. Unfortunately news and education have dumbed all of us down, we have some good financial instruments if one is young, and one if lucky can choose their standard of living in retirement. Most people now think they will pay off their home and social security will give them enough to survive (especially young progressives.) Saving is critical. Real estate, rental property, a business one can sell, stocks, mutual funds are all good instruments to save in assuming the government doesn't screw with them badly.
 
Joined
May 15, 2010
Messages
5,960
Reaction score
8,275
Location
Unfixed Arrow
You must put something back for a rainy day and retirement. It’s going to rain and if you live long enough you’ll retire.
Look to the people that are worth some $ and talk with them. Discuss pros and cons. Most people want to help younger people do well. But don’t take financial advice from broke people. Just like you wouldn’t take diet advice from me.

At minimum, I’d get that “free” 6% that you’re earning every month. Invest it a the 401k across several categories.

Then, I’d set up a Roth for myself and spouse. You can do $500/mo per adult (you and wife). If you can’t do $1k, do a hundred or two. You got $50 extra at the end of the month above the emergency fund, put it in the Roth. You can do this yourself or use a firm like Fidelity, etc.

Once you get to 15% of your gross income going into 401k & Roth, then pay down your debts, smallest to largest. Finishing with the house. Also, may consider college funds for the kiddos as well. You be surprised what $100-150 a month can do in 12-18 years.


The HSA is awesome too. It lowers your taxable income, you can invest inside of it, it withdraws, grows and spends tax free. You should max this out if finances allow. You can even use this well into retirement for medical expenses.

Doing something=better than doing nothing.
 

Raido Free America

Radio Free America
Special Hen
Joined
Jan 24, 2020
Messages
2,461
Reaction score
2,819
Location
Tulsa, OK.
Agree with much of that. Unfortunately news and education have dumbed all of us down, we have some good financial instruments if one is young, and one if lucky can choose their standard of living in retirement. Most people now think they will pay off their home and social security will give them enough to survive (especially young progressives.) Saving is critical. Real estate, rental property, a business one can sell, stocks, mutual funds are all good instruments to save in assuming the government doesn't screw with them badly.
SS has been broke of decades, and is operating on credit now! I seriuously doubt the younger Americans will get anything, from all their FORCED contributions! Whipping a dead horse, gets us nowhere, We tried to plan so we could have a decent life style, no matter what SS did, and if we got SS, that was just a hedge on inflation! That plan turned out to right on! If inflation is 5% per year, it was 12/15% in 2021, for 10 years that is 50%! People living on fixed income standard of living, (parching power) went down 50%! That seems to be the most common mistake I see, starting out with a sufficiant income, but being overwhelmed by inflation! I suspect the, lion feeds on not only the lame antelope, but the ones that don't use their heads as well, and both improve the species?
 
Joined
Jan 14, 2013
Messages
4,781
Reaction score
9,931
Location
Oklahoma City
SS has been broke of decades, and is operating on credit now! I seriuously doubt the younger Americans will get anything, from all their FORCED contributions! Whipping a dead horse, gets us nowhere, We tried to plan so we could have a decent life style, no matter what SS did, and if we got SS, that was just a hedge on inflation! That plan turned out to right on! If inflation is 5% per year, it was 12/15% in 2021, for 10 years that is 50%! People living on fixed income standard of living, (parching power) went down 50%! That seems to be the most common mistake I see, starting out with a sufficiant income, but being overwhelmed by inflation! I suspect the, lion feeds on not only the lame antelope, but the ones that don't use their heads as well, and both improve the species?
I did say progressives, they are still banging the drum on universal income and socialized medicine. Odds are if we do get those healthcare will not pay the cost of treating the diseases that afflict older Americans.
 

sedona

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
Mar 6, 2014
Messages
1,668
Reaction score
1,215
Location
Duncan
My boss made quite a bit more than i did but never invested into a 401k because he was too cheap.I retired several years before he did and he still lives in a 50 year old 1000 square foot house and will rely on social security the rest of his life.SS is a few years away for me but it will be icing on the cake.
 
Joined
Apr 14, 2009
Messages
9,789
Reaction score
12,586
Location
Owasso
Thank you all for your responses. I’m going to contribute 6% to get their match. Rumor is they’re increasing their match next year so Ill probably be increasing again, raises and bonuses should be coming as well. We will see how it plays out.
I built a spreadsheet with each paycheck, showing my pay and the amount of withholdings. I was able to calculate the exact amount of taxes that I will pay over the year and the amount of 401k withholding to keep me in a lower marginal rate. If my calculations are right, I will get an immaterial
refund and I’m saving the higher marginal tax rate by contributing more to my
401k.
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom