Tax break for the rich, smart move. Tax break for poor to eat, moochers?

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Joined
Jan 12, 2007
Messages
30,036
Reaction score
17,653
Location
Collinsville
Not all people that take entitlements pay no tax. Also what about this scenario: The US government spends billions on overspending in many other facets of the budget, why is it ok for a company such as Halliburton to gouge the government when selling their services and then use many loopholes to get out of paying taxes that in reality pay for their services, but its not ok for the US government to buy food for struggling families?

US tax money spent on redundant or overpriced corporate services....GOOD?

US tax money spent on food for needy families......NO GOOD?

Nothing you stated invalidates what I stated.

FWIW, I believe that corporate entitlements are an abomination that invalidates the free enterprise system. They should be straight up eliminated, period. I think corporate tax rates should be a flat 10%, based on whatever business you do in the US. No loopholes, no offshoring mailboxes, etc.
 

Stephen Cue

Sharpshooter
Joined
Jan 17, 2008
Messages
3,837
Reaction score
6
Location
West Tulsa
Wasn't this whole "You didn't build your business" thing already played out by Obama? It seemed to have failed miserably.

I guess that depends on if your predispostition. I understood what Obama meant by his YDBT statement. My firearms instruction business could never have started without the federal governent. Fact!

Business taxes that Wal-Mart pays help go towards those roads and bridges. The fuel taxes that their trucks pay go towards those roads and bridges. The sales tax that they generate goes towards those roads and bridges...

Yes, I agree. That makes my point that they get more benefit. I never stated they didnt pay extra for the extra benefit,
 

HMFIC

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
May 4, 2009
Messages
11,193
Reaction score
11
Location
Tulsa
FWIW, I believe that corporate entitlements are an abomination that invalidates the free enterprise system. They should be straight up eliminated, period. I think corporate tax rates should be a flat 10%, based on whatever business you do in the US. No loopholes, no offshoring mailboxes, etc.

I agree (although 10% might be a bit low).

The fact is that the tax code is a convoluted mess and has been raped over and over again for political gain and means to buy votes. Oh sure, they'll tell you it's to stimulate behavior or encourage certain social or economic things.

So... since I said all of that, can I bash the moochers now? I find it very disturbing that there are so many people on the government dole these days... are they ALL that helpless?
 

Stephen Cue

Sharpshooter
Joined
Jan 17, 2008
Messages
3,837
Reaction score
6
Location
West Tulsa
Nothing you stated invalidates what I stated.


An "entitlements" is something the government takes from others to give to you for free.

Jerry, my statement of 'Not all recipients of entitlements pay no tax was in response to this. Many families that recieve 'entitlements' pay taxes so in essence not all entitlements are free.

FWIW, I believe that corporate entitlements are an abomination that invalidates the free enterprise system. They should be straight up eliminated, period. I think corporate tax rates should be a flat 10%, based on whatever business you do in the US. No loopholes, no offshoring mailboxes, etc.

Agreed.
 

HMFIC

Sharpshooter
Special Hen
Joined
May 4, 2009
Messages
11,193
Reaction score
11
Location
Tulsa
I guess that depends on if your predispostition. I understood what Obama meant by his YDBT statement. My firearms instruction business could never have started without the federal governent. Fact!

I'm guessing that you'd have found a way to start your business without the Goverment's help if it didn't exist. If you're referring to an SBA loan, then I'd also argue that the Government didn't really have much to do with it anyway... it's still a loan from a bank, just backed up by the SBA. If your business plan wasn't solid to begin with, you'd have still been refused. Chances are that if you'd have just gone in without the SBA backing, you might have been successful too. The bottom line there is that millions and millions of Americans every single day find a way to start businesses and make it without Government help. I'm confident that you can too.

EDIT: OH and I wouldn't really consider an SBA loan to be an entitlement anyway.


Yes, I agree. That makes my point that they get more benefit. I never stated they didnt pay extra for the extra benefit,

You don't benefit from the roads that bring all kinds of goods and services to your doorstep? That bring your customers to you? That allow you to travel freely? In fact, you benefit from Wal-Mart being able to thrive as well... It's not as cut and dry as you may wish it to be and quantifying who gets MORE benefit isn't even the point is it?
 

Lurker66

Sharpshooter
Joined
Aug 14, 2012
Messages
9,332
Reaction score
8
Location
Pink
I disagree. I believe it's because liberals feel like it's the governments place to take care of people.

Being a Liberal or conservative has little do with charity or government programs.

If its not the government responsibility, then to whom should we direct our tax dollars. Should the Church? Maybe some huge Company would step up and get a contract with the government.

Maybe care for the poor/elderly/disabled should just be a States issue. Ya think OKs state tax would increase?

Truth is when you go to a grocery store on the 1st you have no real idea of anyones situation. So they use an access card. My wife or daughter uses one every month for a 96y/o grandmother that cant make a grocery list or care for herself.

What is being suggested is that if you use an access/food stamp, government assistance program, you can only buy from a specific list or certain products. Flesh it out and we should have a government run super store that only welfare types can use. That way we can regulate how they eat and spend our tax dollars.
 

Stephen Cue

Sharpshooter
Joined
Jan 17, 2008
Messages
3,837
Reaction score
6
Location
West Tulsa
So... since I said all of that, can I bash the moochers now? I find it very disturbing that there are so many people on the government dole these days... are they ALL that helpless?

Bash all you want, LOL.

No, not all people on the 'dole' are helpless. Are all government loans, grants, tax breaks to rich people legit?
 

Latest posts

Top Bottom