Well, this is quite a conundrum. If those positions paid more than they do, then it wouldn't be necessary for the government to offer incentives such as student loan forgiveness in order to attrack qualified applicants. If they didn't offer such incentives, many people could not afford to take the positions, and the law of supply and demand would require that the government offer more money. Eitherway, it's probably going to cost the taxpayer the same.
Do you object to the military repaying student loans?
/sorry for the thread-jacking. If I was still an Okie, I'd vote no.
I say it depends. Set a limit on the level of student loans that are "forgiven" or "repaid", however you want to word it. The reason is you don't need an Ivy League law degree to work in public service. Public service isn't about finding lawyers with a prestigious background, its about finding lawyers who will work for a quarter of what they're worth (or less).
I believe the military requires X years of service to qualify for a "repayment" program, no? Apply the same requirement. (If I'm wrong, please correct me. I'm not familiar with that program although I hear a lot of ads for it.)